📜 Introduction

At Cigar Circus, we believe great cigars don’t exist in a vacuum — they exist in moments, moods, palates, and expectations. That’s why our Top 10 isn’t based on a single smoke, a single opinion, or a popularity contest.

This list reflects real-world performance across an entire year.

⚖️ Our judging process included:

🔁 Multiple Smoking Sessions

 Every cigar on this list was smoked more than once, often by different members of our team. A great cigar once can be luck. A great cigar repeatedly earns respect.

👥 Multiple Palates & Perspectives

Our selections reflect input from staff, seasoned smokers, casual enthusiasts, and customer feedback — not a single “gatekeeper” palate. 

🕰️ Real-Time Performance Over Time  

We evaluated how cigars smoked fresh, how they held up weeks later, and how consistently they performed across different boxes and batches.  

🏪 Retail & Consumer Feedback  

Sales velocity, reorders, repeat purchases, and in-store conversations mattered. A cigar that people come back for says a lot.

🔥 Construction & Burn Integrity   

Flavor means nothing if the cigar can’t perform. Draw, burn, ash, and overall craftsmanship were critical components.  

🚫 No Paid Placements   

 This is important to us: Manufacturers did not pay to be included. Placement was earned, not bought.

🎟️ Why We Chose Categories Instead of a Straight Ranking  

Traditional “Top 10” lists often miss the bigger picture. They crown one winner and force every cigar — regardless of purpose — into the same lane.

That’s not how people actually smoke cigars.

A morning Connecticut, a bold maduro, a flavored cigar, and a limited collector’s release aren’t competing against each other — they’re serving different moments. Our category-based approach allows:

🎭 Different Experiences to Shine

Create pages from scratch by dragging and dropping customizable building blocks. This system simplifies web design, making it accessible to all skill levels. Combine headers, images, and text sections to build cohesive layouts quickly and efficiently.

 

🔥 Apples-to-Apples Comparisons 

A flawlessly constructed cigar shouldn’t lose to a bolder cigar just because it’s subtler. Categories allow each cigar to be judged on what it’s meant to do best.  

🍬 Room for Every Smoker  

Create pages from scratch by dragging and dropping customizable building blocks. This system simplifies web design, making it accessible to all skill levels. Combine headers, images, and text sections to build cohesive layouts quickly and efficiently.

 

🎪 A Better Story

A flawlessly constructed cigar shouldn’t lose to a bolder cigar just because it’s subtler. Categories allow each cigar to be judged on what it’s meant to do best.  

🏗️ Setting the Foundation for the Future

This isn’t just a list — it’s a framework.

By using consistent categories, transparent judging, and real-world performance metrics, we’re building something we can revisit, refine, and expand every year.

Future lists may evolve. New acts may appear. But the principles remain the same:

• Fair evaluation
• Respect for craftsmanship
• Celebration of variety
• Transparency with our audience

The circus grows — and the show gets better every year.